Key Points
- Initial decisions in incident response are critical for shaping investigations.
- Teams often struggle with scope, evidence preservation, and premature closure.
- Consistency in approach aids in effective incident management.
Incident response effectiveness is often determined by the decisions made immediately after a threat is detected. Contrary to common belief, failures usually stem not from a lack of tools or expertise, but from early missteps during high-pressure situations when information is scarce.
The Importance of Early Decisions
Early in the response process, teams face crucial decisions that set the course for the entire investigation. These moments, often referred to as the ‘first 90 seconds,’ are not about speed but direction. Responders decide what is significant, what to preserve, and whether to consider the issue isolated or part of a larger threat. These choices are pivotal, as they influence subsequent actions and findings.
The ‘first 90 seconds’ is a recurring pattern rather than a one-time event. Each new system identified in an intrusion resets this decision-making clock. As responders assess each system, they must maintain discipline to ensure the investigation remains controlled and comprehensive.
Common Pitfalls in Incident Investigations
Missteps often occur when teams do not fully understand their environments, leading to incomplete investigations. Responders may find themselves answering basic questions under pressure, such as the origins of data egress or the extent of logging. Without prior knowledge, responders lose valuable time learning their systems instead of addressing the incident.
Another frequent issue is the lack of evidence prioritization. Teams may treat all artifacts as equally important, leading to chaotic and inefficient investigations. Focusing on execution evidence, such as malware activity or unauthorized command execution, can help clarify the situation and guide further actions.
Prematurely closing an investigation is another common error. Teams may restore systems too quickly, leaving behind unnoticed threats that can resurface, making it seem like a new incident when it is a continuation of an unresolved issue.
Strategies for Effective Incident Management
Effective incident response relies on consistent methodology and preparation. Teams that understand their environments and practice disciplined response can manage incidents more efficiently. This involves identifying executed actions, preserving critical evidence, and expanding the investigation scope methodically.
Training and experience are key to developing this discipline. Responders improve by learning from mistakes and applying those lessons to future incidents. The goal is not to eliminate all incidents, but to handle them without repetitive errors.
For those looking to strengthen their incident response capabilities, the SANS FOR508 course offers advanced training in incident response, threat hunting, and digital forensics. Scheduled for March 2026 at SANS DC Metro, this course aims to instill the necessary skills for effective incident management.
Conclusion
The initial decisions in incident response play a crucial role in shaping the outcome of an investigation. By focusing on discipline and consistency, responders can navigate complex incidents with confidence. This approach not only aids in immediate response but also prepares teams for future challenges, enabling them to act effectively under pressure.
