Amazon’s smart doorbell subsidiary, Ring, has concluded its collaboration with police surveillance technology company, Flock Safety. This move comes in the wake of public criticism following a Super Bowl advertisement that sparked concerns about a pervasive surveillance environment.
Controversial Advertisement Sparks Debate
The advertisement in question depicted a lost dog being tracked by a network of cameras, leading to fears of a surveillance-driven society. Although the ad focused on a feature called Search Party, it was not directly related to Flock. Ring’s official statement did not attribute the ad as a reason for ending the partnership.
Originally, Ring and Flock had planned to work together to allow Ring camera users to share video footage with law enforcement via a feature known as Community Requests. However, after a detailed review, Ring decided that the integration would require more resources than initially expected.
Mutual Decision to Discontinue Integration
Both companies confirmed that the integration was never initiated, ensuring no customer videos were exchanged. Flock echoed this sentiment, stating the decision was mutual and aimed at better serving their respective customers. Flock remains committed to offering tools that comply with local laws and policies.
Flock, a significant operator of automated license-plate reading systems in the U.S., gathers billions of photos monthly. Despite public concerns, especially during strict immigration enforcement periods, Flock asserts it does not collaborate with Immigration and Customs Enforcement or related agencies.
Ongoing Privacy Concerns Surround Ring
Beyond this partnership, Amazon faces scrutiny over privacy issues associated with its Ring cameras. The Super Bowl ad led to public apprehension about the potential misuse of Ring’s Search Party feature, which aims to locate lost dogs and monitor wildfires. Critics worry it could evolve into a tool for tracking individuals.
Organizations like the Electronic Frontier Foundation have expressed unease over privacy implications. They highlight that Ring’s integration of biometric identification through features like Familiar Faces could potentially combine with neighborhood searches, raising privacy alarms.
Senator Edward Markey has also urged Amazon to halt the Familiar Faces technology. In a letter to Amazon CEO Andrew Jassy, he noted the public’s opposition to Ring’s surveillance methods, as evidenced by reactions to the Super Bowl ad.
This development underscores the growing concern over surveillance technologies and their impact on privacy, prompting companies like Amazon and Flock Safety to reconsider their strategies.
